A Multiplanar Approach is Best for Developing the Glutes

Just over a year ago, I wrote one of my most popular articles titled, “Do More than Just Squat.” In the article, I outlined my belief that gluteus maximus hypertrophy cannot be maximized by any one exercise. For some strange reason, an alarming amount of coaches (might I add that these coaches never have any testimonials showing dramatic glute transformation pictures) will advise women seeking maximum glute development to “just squat.” I believe that this is the worst advice imaginable, which I already wrote about in the linked article. For the record, if you want maximum pec growth, you shouldn’t “just bench,” – you should also perform incline presses and single joint horizontal adduction movements, and if you want maximum back growth, you shouldn’t “just deadlift” – you should also perform chins, pulldowns, and rows. This is common sense just as is the case with glutes and squats – you should also perform hip thrusts and various glute isolation exercises.

glutes

The squat is a great glute exercise for many people. As is the deadlift. As is the lunge. As is the good morning. However, these are all vertically-based hip extension exercises. As a personal trainer, when I started implementing more horizontally-based hip extension exercises such as hip thrusts and back extensions in concert with vertically-based hip extension exercises, my clients started seeing markedly faster and greater results in the glute department. But the glutes aren’t just made for hip extension; the glutes do four distinct things:

  • Hip extension (in varying angles of hip abduction and hip external rotation)
  • Hip abduction (in varying angles of hip flexion)
  • Hip external rotation (in varying angles of hip flexion)
  • Pelvic posterior tilt (PPT is actually similar to hip extension as far as the head of the femur and the acetabulum are concerned)

For this reason, my training programs always include a variety of glute exercises. We make sure to progressively load up our hip thrusts (horizontally-based hip extension) and squats and deadlifts (vertically-based hip extension) for increasing mechanical tension. We employ single leg exercises (vertically-based hip extension) for muscle damage. We employ back extensions (horizontally-based hip extension) and various lateral band exercises (hip abduction and hip external rotation) for metabolic stress. We add some posterior pelvic tilting at the top of our horizontally-based hip extension exercises to increase mechanical tension at the range of motion that maximizes glute activation. We make sure to heavily work the upper glutes and the lower glutes alike. And we use the “same but different” concept by always focusing on the same movement patterns but employing just enough variety to prevent stagnation and keep the gains coming.

Is there any evidence that this approach is superior to the traditional approach of just squatting and possibly deadlifting? Well, I like to think that my extensive Testimonials page provides good evidence, along with my Twin Experiment. However, a brand new paper also sheds some light on this topic.

glute

Just this past week, in HOMO – Journal of Comparative Human Biology, an article was published ahead of print titled, “The cross-sectional area of the gluteus maximus muscle varies according to habitual exercise loading: Implications for activity-related and evolutionary studies.”

The study examined the gluteus maximus size in 6 groups of people. Here’s how the authors described the subjects:

“Several different sports competitors were represented in the sample: 9 volleyball players, 10 high-jumpers, 9 soccer players, 10 squash players, 17 power-lifters, 18 endurance runners, and 18 swimmers. These sports were classified into five categories based on training history: high impact (volleyball players and high-jumpers), odd impact (soccer and squash players), high magnitude (power-lifters), repetitive impact (endurance runners), and repetitive non-impact (swimmers) loading. Definitions of these exercise loading types take into consideration both typical sport performance as well as the typical training regimen, which together establish the exercise loading type of the given sport. Playing volleyball and high-jumping include either maximal jumps and leaps or high impacts from a specific direction during typical sport performance and training, and these sports were considered to represent high-impact loading. Soccer and squash are sports that include rapidly accelerating and decelerating movements and quick turns of the body and the hip region to which they are not normally accustomed; these sports were considered to represent odd-impact loading. The difference between high impact and odd impact loadings was based on the idea of unusual loading direction. Powerlifting involves precise co-ordination of movement coupled with intense muscle force production, and this sport was considered to represent high-magnitude loading. Long-distance running, an endurance sport that includes a great number of repetitive weight-bearing impacts with the ground was considered to represent repetitive impact loading. Swimming is also an endurance sport with a great number of repetitive movements but lacking ground impact; this group was thus considered to represent repetitive non-impact loading”

Here is what the authors found:

Chart II

Chart III

As you can see, powerlifters indeed have markedly larger gluteus maximi than controls (controls still exercised 3 hours per week so they weren’t sedentary), and they had the highest isometric strength. But so did soccer/squash players, as did volleyball players/high jumpers (this group had the highest dynamic strength). Moreover, the gluteus maximi were pretty similar between these three groups, indicating that heavy loading via vertically-based hip extension exercises (powerlifting) isn’t the only way to build the glutes. Various sports have you accelerating and decelerating the body in the vertical, horizontal, lateral, and rotational vectors. These features likely account for the similar gluteus maximi sizes despite the markedly lower loading magnitudes.

Check out the endurance runners and swimmers – their gluteus maximi were not much higher than the controls. The swimming group was training 17 hours per week and still this was not enough to significantly enlarge the glutes. In other words, running and swimming do not build the glutes.

In my opinion, these results do not imply that you have to play sports to maximize glute size; they imply that you should work the glutes in multiple vectors and include a variety of hip extension, hip abduction, and hip external rotation exercises in your training. Sports, sprints, and plyometrics can be risky, but resistance exercises are controlled and predictable and contain a concentric and eccentric component. This study shows that simply activating the glutes to low degrees and performing mundane, repetitive hip extension tasks (running swimming) does not yield glute growth; progressive overload via heavy resistance training and explosive training are needed to significantly enlarge the glutes.

It should be pointed out that this study didn’t examine longitudinal changes in glute size through training…it is possible that individuals with naturally larger glutes gravitate toward sports.

Here are the authors’ conclusions:

“To conclude, muscle activation alone does not result in or require greater muscle size because large muscles are not a prerequisite for endurance type exercise. On the contrary, it seems that rapid and powerful movements favour larger gluteus maximus muscles. Therefore, according to our results, the greater size of M. gluteus maximus is likely to have evolved as a requirement for sprinting and/or jumping movements (for powerful hip extension and stabilizing the trunk against flexion) instead of endurance running or walking. The results of this study demonstrate that active female athletes possess better-developed cranial portions of M. gluteus maximus for high impact, odd impact or high magnitude loading than do a group of less active controls. Moreover, those athletes involved in sports requiring rapid lower limb movements and stabilization of an erect torso possess greater development than do those performing repetitive impact (endurance runners) and repetitive non-impact (swimmers) loadings. It seems likely that sprinting and climbing behaviours would facilitate food acquisition– hunting in addition to aboveground gathering of resources – and both would be implicated in fleeing from danger. Those sports requiring stabilization of an erect torso to provide a stable platform for useof the upper limbs, in this case squash in odd impact group, suggests an equally important evolutionary adaptation favouring development of the cranial portion of M. gluteus maximus. Conversely, endurance running and walking, which are often associated with hunting, do not seem to be sufficient in themselves to account for the development of the cranial portion of M. gluteus maximus.”

In summary, do more than just squat and deadlift for maximum gluteal development; make sure to incorporate glute exercises that have you extending the hips, abducting the hips, and externally rotating the hips. This is what we do in Strong Curves and Get Glutes, and it’s what my Glute Squad does out of my Glute Lab. It’s what my client Erin did to win her first overall in bikini. It works for me/them and it’ll work for you.

1

 

16 Comments

  • Prianka says:

    Hi Bret, great article! That’s exactly what I’m trying to do now, a range of exercises with high and low weights to vary my rep range. However, I really feel that hill sprinting helps my overall body look better and I only do it as an interval sprint-walk-jog session for about 15 mins after my glute workout. Is this not ok?

  • Matt says:

    Short and sweet; I like it. Aside from the in-depth analysis, that first paragraph (title too) is the key. If an assistance exercise will assist you in reaching your goal, you’d be a fool to not add it in.

    The study was definitely interesting. You don’t think of soccer players having large glutes for some reason. I never saw that coming.

  • Iris says:

    The study seems to conclude that gluteal development is the result of playing some types of sports continuously. It can be just as possible that people who naturally have larger and stronger glutes excel in different sports than those who don’t. If you have week glutes you won’t perform very well in a sport where a lot of jumping is required. You won’t find strong glutes in a world class distance runner as it is not required for that sport where those with low body mass perform best.If you have an elite distance runner play volleybal intensely over a couple of years he won’t turn out to have great glutes. Chances are, however, he’ll make at best a mediocre volleyball player as he isn’t build for that sport.

  • Iris says:

    Another thing (this doesn’t go to your adress, it isjust an observation as “sprinting” was mentioned) is that what recreational athletes do when they think they are sprinting is not sprinting. What they do is fast jogging over a short distance. They won’t use their muscles the same way reasonably fast sprinters do . If people do that kind of interval running and enjoy it, that is great. If they expect sprint-specific results from it they should be prepared to be disappointed.

  • Jon says:

    This article makes me wonder about a fascinating, under-studied topic: the glute activation and development inherent in the two olympic lifts. Massive, explosive hip extension is the most important driver of the lifts; under-extending the hips is the chief beginner mistake, which I still make. Then there’s the matter of jumping under the bar, and the jump training inherent in this. Olympic lifters have massive vertical jumps, can easily do backflips, etc. They also have enormous legs and glutes, and they don’t do standard glute thrusts, but obviously squat a ton.

    I would love to see research comparing the role of the glutes in the second pull of the snatch and clean, versus squats, jumping, and glute thrusts.

  • Jim says:

    Jon, that is a great observation. It is my personal belief that the reason Olympic lifter have such great glute development despite the fact that most of their glute work comes from squatting is that they tend to be posterior dominant athletes. They don’t have the glute and hamstring amnesia so common in our modern society even amongst athletes. I think that training for a display of power as opposed to training just for strength helps the body to recruit the glutes and hamstrings to an appropriate level. Most forms of training do not occur at a great enough velocity to elicit this level of adaption towards greater movement efficiency.

  • Jenny says:

    Speaking of athletes…these ladies have perfect glutes! You know you are glute obsessed when it’s the first thing you notice! (Though, who wouldn’t right!?) https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/64/a5/59/64a559a3496ab1d03f030cfff8e5fc41.jpg

    • Jenny says:

      Nubian Warrior Women of Kau, Sudan

      • Jim says:

        I am of African decent but I never liked the term black as a description of myself or most other people with dark skin as I am not black in color but brown. Those women are black and beautiful. They look like their skin is made of flawless obsidian. Amazing.

  • Irma says:

    Fascinating. As a former swimmer, I wish I had incorporated more glute activation workouts into my training. I think it would have had a very positive impact on the backstroke start, the fly kick and breastroke kick. It would be cool if you could do an experiment and test whether swimmers can improve their starts length and force.

    Unrelated, but I would really love to hear your input on Mark Rippletoe’s T-Nation article, “Strength Training for Women.” Especially regarding his preference for more sets, less reps for strength as opposed to less sets with longer repetitions.

    Cheers!

  • Ari says:

    Hello! I was wondering, do you have an email that I could reach you at? I don’t do social media and I really wanted to contact you for advice. I’m having an issue with my training that my doctor and teacher can not figure out. I’m a cpt and a dietetics student and what my body is doing does not make sense. It’s defying every ounce of math and science I know…and I get all A’s. I truly feel that if anyone can help me, it is you.

  • Jose says:

    Hi Bret,

    Did the study consider the possibility that soccer/squash and voleiball players did strength training as part of their training program? That could confound the results.

  • Daniela says:

    Would love to have seen a cross comparison with stunt actors/actresses!

  • Amna says:

    Hello Bret,

    What degree of hip flexion during hip abduction works the upper glutes the most? You see people using the hip abduction machine in too many ways to count..

    Thank you

  • Amna says:

    Hello Bret,

    What angle of hip flexion in hip abduction best works the upper glutes? People use the hip abduction machine in too many ways to count…

    Thank you

  • […] (among others). From what I have read and now through trial and error on my own, you must work your glutes more often than once a week! It’s important to also space out your sets – in other words, doing TONS of exercises on […]

Leave a Reply

SIGN UP FOR THE FREE NEWSLETTER

and receive my FREE Lower Body Progressions eBook!

You have Successfully Subscribed!